How To Restore Pampered Chef Stoneware

How to Restore Pampered Chef Stoneware ( a Tale of the Recalcitrant Husband) – You know how there is that one thing that your significant other does that just really irritates you to no end? That one thing that no matter what you do or say, they seem determined to drive you mad by continuing to do it. Maybe for you, it is hair in the sink, or clothes on the floor. Well, for me it is doing the dishes properly.

A few weeks ago, I wrote in a post about how I had been down with the flu. It was a bad case that didn’t want to let up, and it took me almost two weeks to fully recover. Luckily, I have a wonderful husband who is great at handling (most) things.

For an entire week, I was so ill that just dragging myself out of bed was a feat of astronomical proportions. “Don’t worry about it”, he said. “I’ve got it all under control,” he said. 

Frankly, at the time, I couldn’t care less if he destroyed the whole house, as long as I had my tissues and a dark quiet room. Of course, that wasn’t my feeling once I recovered enough to see what had happened to my beloved stoneware.

Now, I know he knows better! Seriously, my husband is an incredibly intelligent man. Plus, I have preached for years about my persnickety rules for washing dishes. 

“Silverware goes right side up. Bowls go right side down. And never, ever put wood, cast iron, or stoneware in the dishwasher”. 

For the life of me, I can’t figure out why he is determined to destroy my cookware! But, since he spent the whole week taking care of the kids by himself, I didn’t complain…much.

This is what my stoneware looked like. I am still at a loss as to what exactly he did to get it to look like this. All I know is I found it in the dishwasher with all of the gorgeous seasoning gone and some serious crust residue all along the edges. 

There was no way to remove that crust! I thought that I might have to dispose of the thing. But first, I wanted to try my technique for restoring stoneware.

(Normal) Way To Care for Pampered Chef Stoneware

If you are new to using this product, you should know that Pampered Chef stoneware comes with a list of what to do and not do. Just to name a few…

You are supposed to properly season them before using them. You shouldn’t preheat them (which I totally ignore for my pizza stone). Never use soap to clean them. 

You shouldn’t subject them to drastic changes in temperatures, and you are supposed to have most of the surface covered when cooking on them.

To clean them, the provide you with a little plastic scraper to do the heavy work. But, for the most part, these things are not meant to be washed in the traditional fashion. Just a light rinse and dry is what is recommended.

Personally, I have mostly just done whatever I felt like with mine. I’ve on occasion used soap and a scrub daddy. I cook a little, or I cook a lot, with no thought to how much surface is covered. But one thing that I have always been careful of is a change in temperature.

A Few Things About Temperature Changes

Stoneware can and will break if subjected to temperature changes too quickly. I have even noticed that there have been a lot of complaints over the past year about them breaking unexpectedly. 

I don’t know if this is caused by a new, but inferior, manufacturing method, or if it is caused by mishandling. All I know is that mine has been going strong for well over 10 years.

I should also note that what I did to restore my stoneware is not recommended by the manufacturer. So, proceed at your own risk. 

However, I have done this before without causing any negative results. I will say, though, that I only do this when the only alternative is disposal, or when the seasoning has gotten so thick that it begins to flake. 

Re-Setting My Pampered Chef Stoneware to Like-New

So, what did I do? How did I go from a ruined stone to an almost new one? Well, I used my self-cleaning oven. 

That’s right. I popped the stone in and set it to self-clean for about two hrs. After the two hours were up, all that was left was a bit of ash. 

I tried and tried other methods, but nothing could take away all the baked-on and set-in crust without ending up with chemicals soaked into the stone. So, this was my last-ditch effort.

Just an FYI – this will work on all the Pampered Chef’s pizza pans, bar pan’s, and any of the traditional stoneware as long as it is the “traditional” stone. This doesn’t apply to the ceramic covered stuff or anything new that may appear in the future.

It is best for burnt stoneware and crusty layers that need to be removed, But, there are a few tricks to getting this done, as well as a few precautions that you will need to take.

1. Ventilation Is Required

Since this technique worked so well, I have done it several times on all of my stoneware. Because of the natural odors produced by the self-cleaning oven, I highly recommend good ventilation.

I now schedule my stone reset to be done during spring cleaning, if I notice that they are needing it. In fact, if I have a flaking stone, I add the task of restoring it to my spring cleaning list. I wait for a nice breezy day is nice, open all the windows, and let the airflow while the oven is running.

2. Start with A Clean Oven

I only run my stoneware through the self-cleaning cycle on a completely clean oven. I never try to clean both at the same time. It is simply too much of a smell for me to tolerate. So, if the oven needs cleaning, I do that first.

3. Allow Stoneware to Completely Cool

And when the cycle is finished, I leave it until it has completely cooled. This is probably the most important step. You don’t want to remove the stoneware while it is still hot. (Remember the change in temperature rule). Once it has cooled to the touch, then I take it out and rinse away the leftover ash.

I place the stone directly on the bottom of the oven. My oven has a hidden bottom element, so I can do that. But, if you have an exposed element, place it on the bottom rack. This will leave a bit of headroom just in case it throws a grease flame. (more on that below).

Safety Concerns Surrounding Oven Fires

As you probably already know, there is some debate about whether using the self-cleaning feature of an oven is safe due to the by-products it can produce. I won’t go into all of that today, but I do want to address the potential for grease fires.

If you have ever had a fire occur inside your oven, you know that it can be pretty scary. It usually occurs because there is a fresh spill or a greasy piece of food left in the oven. Thankfully, this is a rare occurrence with cleaning. But, it can and does occasionally happen. 

As far as the stones are concerned, you should not attempt to clean a heavy coated stone, especially one with a fresh oil layer, without following the precautions listed below in number 4. (Bold text to emphasize)

How to Prevent Oven Fires

Some ovens are more prone to this condition than others. But, if your oven is in proper working order and you follow a few steps, you should not have a problem.

1. Never run a self-cleaning cycle if the seal on your oven is damaged or malfunctioning.
2. As mentioned before, don’t try to clean your oven and your stoneware in one round. Break it down into steps to reduce the workload on the oven and to reduce the fumes.
3. Never leave your home while running the self-clean mode. 
4. Always remove the heavy, sticky, and large build-up particles before running the stone through the self-cleaning mode.
   
   If you have a lot of thick build-up on your stone, you can breakdown a lot of the grease and oils by soaking the stone in hot water for several hours. Scrap away any large clumps of burned on particles. 
   
   Try running it through the dishwasher, first. Put the setting on hot and do NOT use any detergent. This is the only time that I would recommend doing so.
   
   Although I was not happy with my husband running my stone through the dishwasher, it did have one benefit. It removed all of the fresher oil layers. What was left behind, while impossible to remove by hand, was quite agreeable with the oven’s self-cleaning function.
   
   After using this technique on multiple pieces, I have discovered one thing for certain. If the fresh oils are broken down/removed prior to going into the oven, the cleaning mode works perfectly.

What To Do If You Do Get an Oven Fire

• First of all, don’t panic. Your oven was made to handle high temperatures. While flames are scary, they normally die down within a few minutes on their own. If your oven seal is functioning properly, the fire is contained.
• Cancel the cleaning cycle and allow the oven to cool. If your oven is one of those that doesn’t allow you to end a cleaning cycle mid-way through, be familiar with how you would wish to disconnect the power. The easiest and safest way is to simply flip the switch in your electric box. Pulling the plug should be your last resort because you can burn yourself trying to get to it.
• NEVER open the door while the flames are active. It may be your natural reaction to want to douse the fire with baking soda, but opening the door can result in severe burns and provide additional oxygen to the flames. 
• After the oven has cooled, remove the stone and do a proper presoak/wash cycle as described in number 4 above. Then, restart the cleaning process.

Final Comments…

As you can see, my pan was restored to almost new condition. It just needs to be re-seasoned and it will be good to go. I will caution you, though. This isn’t a process to be taken lightly. 

I can’t promise that your stone won’t break – especially since there may be issues with the newer stones. What I can tell you is that if you need to reset your Pampered Chef stoneware, this method works. However, as I said before, I would just recommend doing this when there is no other alternative.

(And sweety, if you are reading this, you know I love you.) :-)